Two popular software packages are TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA. Both tax prep packages offer you the chance to do your own taxes, with free editions as well as paid features.
TurboTax covers more situations than its competitor, and is known for its customer service and trustworthiness. Additionally, TurboTax is often hailed for its feature-rich and intuitive platform
FreeTaxUSA also has a user-friendly interface and is thorough. Additionally, it has a much lower price point. As long as you don’t have an unduly complicated tax situation, and you don’t need access to the same level of customer service, there’s a good chance that FreeTaxUSA will be sufficient for your needs.
Here’s what you need to know about TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA.
Table of Contents:
TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA Overview:
|TurboTax||Free||Simple returns||$0 Federal, $0 State|
|TurboTax||Deluxe||Homeowners and filers wanting to maximize deductions and credits||$60 Federal, $50 State|
|TurboTax||Premier||Those who have investments and rental properties||$90 Federal, $50 State|
|TurboTax||Self-Employed||Freelancers and small business owners||$120 Federal, $50 State|
|TurboTax Live||Basic, Deluxe, Premier and Self-Employed||Filers wanting unlimited guidance and help from a CPA or EA||$80 - $200 Federal, $55 State|
|FreeTaxUSA||Free||Confident filers needing minimal guidance||$0 Federal, $14.99 State|
|FreeTaxUSA||Deluxe||Confident filers looking for DIY audit support||$6.99, $14.99 State|
Prices are up-to-date as of January 24, 2020.
TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA: Filing Versions
FreeTaxUSA simplifies matters by offering only two versions of its software, Free and Deluxe. You get most tax filing situations with the Free version–even K-1 forms. Upgrading to Deluxe gives you access to increased support options, including Audit Assist.
There are some situations that FreeTaxUSA can’t help you with, though. If you have foreign employment income or have a situation that includes other complications, like a foreign mailing address or if your children have more than $2,000 in investment income, this version can’t help you. The more complicated things get, the less likely FreeTaxUSA is the right choice.
Read More: FreeTaxUSA Full Review
TurboTax, on the other hand, has several different versions, with the Free version supporting only a very limited set of circumstances. As you buy progressively more expensive versions of TurboTax, you get access to a wider variety of forms. You can also purchase upgraded services from TurboTax, some of which are more complete and accessible than what you get with FreeTaxUSA.
Both FreeTaxUSA and TurboTax offer state forms. However, if you qualify for the free version of TurboTax, you don’t have to pay to file your state tax return. FreeTaxUSA charges for each state tax return from the get-go. Once you move into paid versions of TurboTax, though, you’re charged for state returns. And FreeTaxUSA only charges $14.99 per state, while TurboTax charges $50 per state return.
Read More: TurboTax Full Review
TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA: Ease of Use
Both TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA are easy to use. FreeTaxUSA has fewer bells and whistles, though. Plus, with FreeTaxUSA, you pretty much have to go in order of the tax form. No skipping around. It works best if you’re ready to sit down and finish your taxes in one sitting. The interface is clean and easy to read and simple to use, even if it doesn’t take you through step by step.
On the other hand, TurboTax is known for its feature-rich platform that does a lot of hand-holding. It’s possible to upload forms as you get them, and work on different areas of your tax return. TurboTax also has an easy-to-follow question format that almost feels like you’re sitting down with a tax preparer to get a feel for your situation. With TurboTax, you can start with one version and if you realize you have a more complicated tax situation, you can upgrade to another version. You aren’t charged until you’re ready to file your taxes.
TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA: Audit Help
TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA both offer DIY audit support, meaning you get help learning how to respond to the IRS. However, FreeTaxUSA only offers its Audit Assist product if you pay for the Deluxe version. TurboTax has a more robust version with its third-party service called MAX. Though, you have to pay an additional $49.99 to get full-service audit help with TurboTax.
If you’re not afraid of being audited, and if you think you can handle most correspondence with the IRS on your own, the lower-cost FreeTaxUSA Deluxe version can provide you with what you need to handle the situation. However, if you’re worried about an audit and want maximum protection and help, paying for the TurboTax add-on at the time you file can give you greater peace of mind.
TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA: Customer Service
In general, the customer service options available through FreeTaxUSA are fairly limited. You get free access to the customer support page, and if you pay for the Deluxe version, you can get chat support or use the searchable Q&A database. However, direct customer support isn’t very accessible, so if you’re looking for a great deal of help, you’re not likely to find it with FreeTaxUSA.
On the other hand, TurboTax offers extensive customer service options, including access to a searchable online database, email, and phone. For an additional fee, you can also get help with tax questions, by accessing a tax professional. TurboTax also offers help with TurboTax Live, an additional service that allows screen sharing with a professional who can walk you through your situation.
When it comes time to file, you’re on your own with FreeTaxUSA. You’ll pay your fee and submit, and that’s it. However, TurboTax gives you the option of paying to have a tax professional review your return and then sign it and file it for you. If you want an extra set of eyes to take a look, TurboTax is the better option.
TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA: Pricing
This is where FreeTaxUSA really shines. While you can get the free version, even for more complex tax situations, anything extra you do comes with additional costs. State filings, amending your tax return, and priority customer support all come with extra costs when you get the free version. However, if you pay $6.99 for the Deluxe version, you can get most of those services included, although you still have to pay to file a state return.
Related: Get the Cheapest Tax Software
If you get the Deluxe version of FreeTaxUSA and file a state return, you can get the whole thing for $21.98. That’s a pretty good deal. Filing amended returns comes with an additional fee of $14.99.
TurboTax is one of the priciest tax prep software products on the market. There are several versions, and the free version is only available to those with the simplest of tax situations. If you get the Deluxe version, which is the next step up from free, you’re looking at a minimum of $60 to file your federal return and $50 to file one state tax return. That’s a total of $110.
If you want to add TurboTax Live to your product, it’s going to cost even more, but you do get access to live help from tax professionals–something that’s not even an option when you use FreeTaxUSA. If you get TurboTax Live for Self-Employed and add a state return, you’ll pay $255. Add the audit defense product on for another $49.99, and you’re paying $304.99 to get the total package from TurboTax.
However, even with that pricing, TurboTax still might coss less than hiring a CPA to do your taxes.
In the end, which product you choose depends on your tax needs and how much you’re willing to pay.
FreeTaxUSA is much cheaper, but in many ways, you get what you pay for. FreeTaxUSA is fine for confident filers who are reasonably sure they can handle most of their taxes on their own, with only a little guidance. There aren’t a lot of extras and features, so if you’re looking for something that’s almost like having a tax professional walking you through it, FreeTaxUSA probably won’t do the trick.
On the other hand, if you’re willing to pay more for access to help and features, TurboTax can be a great choice and covers a wider variety of complicated situations. Plus, you can pay to get access to dedicated audit help. The more complex your situation, the more likely you are to be audited, so this feature is excellent for your peace of mind.