Editor's note - You can trust the integrity of our balanced, independent financial advice. We may, however, receive compensation from the issuers of some products mentioned in this article. Opinions are the author's alone, and this content has not been provided by, reviewed, approved or endorsed by any advertiser.

The question of whether to invest in a Roth or traditional has come up a lot lately. Previously, I wrote about these retirement accounts in the The Ultimate Guide to Traditional and Roth 401(k) and IRA Retirement Accounts. In that article I linked to a Roth 401(k) calculator that can help you determine what’s best for you. I wanted to point out, however, that the decision is not necessarily one or the other. If your employer offers both Roth and traditional 401(k) plans, typically you can chose to invest in both. Your total contributions cannot exceed the IRS limits ($19,000 in 2019 + $6,000 catch up for those 50 and older). But within this limit, you can invest a portion in a traditional plan and a portion in a Roth plan. I can think of at least two good reasons to consider splitting your investment into both types of plans.

First, you may conclude that the best plan for you depends on what your tax rate will be during retirement. The problem is, of course, that we can’t know for sure what the tax situation will be many years from now. Since we don’t know, why not invest some of your money in both plans? By doing so, you hedge against the possibility that you’ll put all your money in one plan that turns out to be the second best choice.

Second, you may conclude that the Roth is best, but can’t afford to lose the current tax savings that a traditional 401(k) offers. If that’s the case, you can start off investing some small portion in the Roth plan, and as your income grows (and your need for the tax deduction diminishes), you can gradually switch your contributions from the traditional plan to a Roth plan.

It’s this second option that I’m seriously considering when my employer begins offering the Roth 401(k). And since my company matches dollar for dollar up to 6%, putting all my money in a Roth 401(k) would result in the first option. Why? Because matching contributions are placed in a traditional 401(k), even if the employee contributions go to a Roth 401(k).


Finally, if you’re funding a 401(k), you may also want to consider signing up for blooom. It’s the only dedicated robo-advisor for 401(k) accounts. Blooom gives you a free analysis of your retirement plan and for $10 a month, blooom will manage your 401(k). This includes finding and minimizing hidden fees, regularly adjusting your portfolio, expert financial help from blooom advisors and suspicious activity alerts to protect your account. blooom can work with any employer sponsored retirement plan and is currently the only robo-advisor available that specifically manages 401(k) accounts. You can learn more about blooom here.

Next Steps

Author Bio

Total Articles: 1080
Rob founded the Dough Roller in 2007. A litigation attorney in the securities industry, he lives in Northern Virginia with his wife, their two teenagers, and the family mascot, a shih tzu named Sophie.

Article comments

Randall says:

I like the Roth 401(k), it’s just that no company I’ve worked at has ever offered one yet. I ‘believe’ that taxes will have to go up, maybe even significantly, with all the pending issues the U.S. is facing in the coming decades; Social Security solvency, Boomers retiring, Economic slowdowns, etc.

If I’m wrong, then I lost a little money. If I’m right, those in a taxable account stand to possibly lose a LOT of money.

The other thing I like is the ‘don’t have to take disbursements at 70 1/2’ If I want to leave it in there to accumulate interest, I can. Conventional Roths and IRAs force you to take it out whether you want/need to or not.

DR says:

Randall, I too suspect that taxes will have to go up. Social Security and medicare will cost us a fortune. You’d be surprised, though, how close a call a traditional versus Roth 401(k) is even if you assume taxes will go up. The calculator I link to in the article allows you to set different tax scenarios to test this. Good luck!

Emeka says:

I have read some of your articles and think they are brilliant. They are very great and relevant for everyone more especially the younger generation.

I contribute to my company’s 401k and am matched at 75% for the first 6%. Currently am putting in the 6% which is in a traditional 401k and also contributing to a Roth IRA. My personal contribution is about equal for both the Roth IRA and the traditional 401k . My company offers the Roth 401k and I want to know if I should switch over. Should I stay how I am and be tax diversified as we dont know what future tax laws are OR should I go with the Roth and enjoy the tax-free withdrawals. I am 24 years old and believe my tax rate will go up.

DR says:

Emeka, I’m glad you’re finding the site useful. As for Roth versus traditional retirement accounts, you may won’t to try a calculator that can help you determine which is best for you. I’ve included a link to one in the following post: The Ultimate Guide to Traditional and Roth 401(k) and IRA Retirement Accounts.

George Adams says:

Another advantage of the Roth 401(k) over a Traditional 401(k) is with unqualified distributions.

Say you put in $10,000 in both a Traditional 401(k) and Roth 401(k), and both grow in value to $15,000. Later, you leave your company and roll both accounts over into (respectively) a Traditional IRA and Roth IRA.

And then let’s say you need some money, but you haven’t hit age 59 1/2 or any other qualifying event.

With the Traditional IRA, you will be hit with penalties if you try to withdraw any of that money. But with the Roth IRA, you can withdraw any or all of your contributions without penalty at any time. So if you need up to $10,000 from that IRA, it’s yours for the taking.

We plan on using that as a form of college savings for our kids. Almost all our excess money will be going to my Roth 401(k) rather than a 529 college savings plan. Later, if we need extra money for our kids’ college, I’ll be able to pull out some of my contributions to my Roth IRA (rolled over from the Roth 401(k)) to help foot the bill.

Ashish Kachrani says:

George Adams — Why would you use Roth 401k instead of 529 college savings. 529 plans has it own set of benefits that are not offered in Roth?

komrad says:

Let’s say your income is too high for a TIRA or RIRA, but if you invest in a 401k to reduce your taxable income, then you can participate in a Roth IRA. Given that scenario, how would you allocate your stocks versus your bonds? ie. would stocks go into the 401k, and bonds in the Roth, or the opposite?

Rob Berger says:

One theory is to invest in stocks in a Roth as they are more likely to grow more than bonds.

david says:

I have returned to my old company (8yrs inbtw.) that I had tranditional 401k with a balance and never rolled over to IRA or Roth IRA. now that i’m back that money has grew doubled. i am only interested in Roth 401k offered by my work 100% up to 4% match. should I leave the money that i have not contributed on trad. 401k as is and only contribute to Roth 401k offered at wrk? there is no option to convert trad. 401k to roth 401k w. current employer that i have returned.

Dave Copeland says:

I have the option with Vanguard to contribute to a 401(k) and Roth 401(k). I also have the option to contribute “After Tax Unmatched Contributions up to 15%”. I’m wondering if they are nice enough to automatically put the after tax unmatched into the Roth 401(k) for me? Anyone have any thoughts?