How Half a Percent Can Ruin Your Retirement

Last year one of my largest expenses was one I never saw. I didn’t get a bill for it. And I didn’t have to pay it, at least not directly. But it still cost me a small fortune. I’m talking about investment costs in the form of mutual fund expenses.

Mutual fund expenses present two big problems. First, because you don’t actually get billed for them, it’s easy to forget about them. The cost comes out of your investments, so you never have to write a check for the expense. If you invest in mutual funds through a 401k, IRA or taxable account, you have the same problem.

The second problem, and the one we are going to look at today, is that even small expenses can add up over time. Because we save and invest for retirement over several decades, even half a percent can have a huge impact on our retirement. In fact, an extra 0.50% paid in mutual fund fees can be the difference between a comfortable retirement and living on a shoestring budget.

Here’s why expenses are so important. The difference between paying say 0.5% and 1% in fees for your mutual funds is ENORMOUS over a 40 year (25 to 65) investment period. Here’s the math, assuming you start with nothing and add $1,000 a month to your retirement savings (take a guess at the difference before you read on):

Average ReturnBalance after 40 Years
8.00%$3,514,281.66
7.50%$3,042,721.15

So given the effect of even 0.50% on retirement savings, there are two things we need to do: (1) determine the cost of our retirement investments; and (2) depending on the results, make changes to reduce our costs.

Determining the cost of your investments

If you have invested in just one mutual fund, determining your investment costs is easy—just look at the fund’s expense ratio. If you don’t know where to look, simply get the ticker symbol of your fund (which should be on your last statement) and enter it into the Google search box. For example, when I enter VEIEX (a Vanguard emerging market index fund that I’ve owned since 2002) into Google, this is the first result:

VEIEX Google Search

As you can see, the expense ratio is 0.35%. That means that for every $100 invested in the VEIEX fund, you’ll pay 35 cents in expenses each year.

Now, if you own more than one fund, you’ll want to calculate your weighted average cost. To do that, for each fund you own perform the following calculation:

Amount invested in fund / Total invested in all funds x Fund’s expense ratio

So for example, if I had $10,000 invested in VEIEX and a total portfolio of $100,000, my calculation for VEIEX would look like this:

$10,000 / $100,000 x .35% = .035

Perform the same calculation for each fund you own, and add up the results. What you’ll get is the weighted average cost of your funds.

And if you hate math, then track your portfolio in Morningstar (it’s free), which calculates the weighted average cost of your portfolio for you (here are the details).

You should aim for a weighted average cost of no more than 0.5%, in my opinion. If your costs are significantly higher, keep reading.

How to reduce the cost of retirement investing

There are several ways to reduce the cost of investing for your retirement:

  • Invest in index funds: Index funds generally have significantly lower expense ratios than do actively management funds. Because index funds track an index like the S&P 500, you don’t have to pay for the cost of investmen managers to evaluate and pick stocks. And the performance of index funds generally beat managed funds over the long haul anyway.
  • Invest in ETFs: Exchange traded funds typically have a lower expense ratio than identical mutual funds. You do have to pay a brokerage fee to buy ETFs, but unless you are an active trader, the fee should be less over the long term than the extra expenses you’d pay for a mutual fund. I recently purchased ITF for my SEP IRA at Scottrade. The brokerage fee was just $7.95.
  • Reduce trading costs: If you are a fairly active trader, you must watch the transaction costs of your investment activity. There are plenty of low cost online brokers to choose from. I use Scottrade because it has branches everywhere, but you can find even less expensive brokers like OptionsHouse ($3.95 stock trades) and Zecco ($4.95 stock trades.

NEXT–>How to Find the Hidden Cost of Mutual Funds

Published or Updated: June 10, 2013
About Rob Berger

Rob founded the Dough Roller in 2007. A litigation attorney in the securities industry, he lives in Northern Virginia with his wife, their two teenagers, and the family mascot, a shih tzu named Sophie.

Comments

  1. Money Beagle says:

    I just went through my 401(k) the other day and looked at fees of all the accounts I am/was invested in. Anything that had a fee of over 1% a year, I transferred money out of. That’s outrageous. The sad thing is that they are higher risk funds that didn’t do so well last year anyways, so it was a big double whammy.

Speak Your Mind

*